Inside 'All Out': A Deep Dive into Simon Rich's Latest Broadway Hit

Broadway has long been a stage for innovation and star power, and Simon Rich's latest production, All Out: Comedy About Ambition, is no exception. This comedic exploration of ego, envy, and the quintessential New Yorker has captivated audiences since its debut, thanks in part to its unique format and a rotating cast of renowned performers.

The Concept: A Rotating Cast and Fresh Perspectives

Following the success of All In: Comedy About Love, Rich's previous hit, All Out continues the tradition of bringing together a diverse group of comedians to perform live readings of Rich's short stories. Each performance features a different ensemble, offering audiences a fresh experience every time. The show, directed by Tony Award-winner Alex Timbers, began its run at the Nederlander Theatre on December 12, 2025, and is scheduled to conclude on March 8, 2026.

Jake Shane's Broadway Debut: A Digital Star Takes the Stage

Among the notable talents gracing the All Out stage is Jake Shane, a comedian and podcaster making his Broadway debut. Shane, known for his podcast Therapuss with Jake Shane and his viral TikTok videos reenacting historical events, joined the cast on February 17, 2026. His inclusion marks a significant crossover from digital platforms to traditional theater, reflecting the evolving landscape of entertainment.

Shane's rise to prominence has been meteoric. Since 2023, he has amassed over five million followers across social media platforms. In 2025, he was honored with a Webby Award for Best Comedy Creator. His podcast has consistently ranked high on Spotify's Top Comedy Podcasts chart, and its third season is set to premiere on Netflix on February 18, 2026. Additionally, Shane has appeared in the fourth season of the acclaimed series Hacks and is developing a Hulu comedy series inspired by his own life.

A Star-Studded Lineup: Comedy's Finest Unite

All Out boasts an impressive roster of comedic talent. Alongside Shane, the final weeks of the production feature Broadway debuts from Ray Romano, Nicholas Braun, and Jenny Slate. Previous casts have included luminaries such as Jon Stewart, Eric Andre, Jim Gaffigan, Wayne Brady, Cecily Strong, Heidi Gardner, Jason Mantzoukas, and Craig Robinson. This rotating lineup ensures that each performance offers a unique blend of humor and perspective.

Behind the Scenes: Creative Minds at Work

The production's success is also attributed to its creative team. Directed by Alex Timbers, known for his work on Oh, Hello, the show features original music performed live by the soul-pop band Lawrence. The creative team includes scenic designer David Korins, costume designer Jennifer Moeller, lighting designer Jake DeGroot, sound designer Peter Hylenski, and video designer Lucy Mackinnon. Producers Seaview and Lorne Michaels, along with Micah Frank and Caroline Maroney on behalf of Broadway Video, have brought Rich's vision to life on the Broadway stage.

As All Out: Comedy About Ambition approaches the end of its limited engagement, it stands as a testament to the dynamic nature of Broadway, where traditional theater and digital-age talent converge to create unforgettable experiences.